Knowledge Base › Disfellowshipping
I just stopped.
The first steps in the outside world: about the emptiness, rethinking your identity, and building a new routine.
Familiar questions Why does freedom suddenly feel so strange? Why do I miss my old routine even though I wanted to stop? Who am I if I no longer see myself as one of Jehovah’s Witnesses? What do I do with evenings and weekends that suddenly feel empty? Do I need to figure out right away what I do believe? Why do relief, grief, anger, and doubt keep alternating? How do I build a new life without having to change everything at once? And what if sometimes I long for what I left behind? Maybe you decided on your own to stop attending meetings and going out in field service. Maybe you gradually became less active. Maybe you were removed from the congregation or officially made it known that you no longer wanted to be one of Jehovah’s Witnesses. Those situations are not the same. The consequences are not the same for everyone either. Some people keep a lot of contact with family and friends, while others see a large part of their social circle change. Some feel mostly relief. Others feel sadness, fear, or confusion. And many people can experience different feelings at the same time. What can happen when a long-familiar religious routine changes is something unexpected: space opens up. No meeting that evening. No field service that morning. No preparation still to do. Maybe no daily text anymore. No convention you have to take into account. Suddenly you have time. But knowing what you want to do with that time is something else entirely. “Free time” can feel strange When you’ve had a fixed weekly structure for years, a free Saturday or Sunday morning can feel surprisingly unfamiliar. Maybe you had longed for that freedom. And yet you’re sitting at home thinking: What am I supposed to do now? That doesn’t have to mean you made the wrong decision. It also doesn’t prove that you actually want to go back. You may not even miss the faith itself. You may simply notice that a familiar structure has disappeared . A routine can give you something to hold on to, even when you no longer support everything that happened within that routine. That is why it helps to keep two questions separate: Do I miss my faith? and: Do I miss structure, people, familiarity, or the feeling of belonging somewhere? The answer can also be a combination of those things. You don’t have to fill the emptiness right away After a busy, highly organized life, there can be a tendency to fill every empty space immediately. A new hobby. Sports. Going out. Traveling. Dating. New friends. Courses. Research into Jehovah’s Witnesses. Watching videos for hours. Reading everything you didn’t read before. But freedom doesn’t have to become productive right away. Maybe one of the strangest things you have to relearn is: that an empty evening is allowed to just be an empty evening. You don’t have to do anything for the congregation. But you also don’t have to prove right away that you now have an amazing life outside the organization. Maybe you feel guilty when you do nothing Some former JWs notice that the activity is gone, but the feeling of having to is still there. You sleep in on Saturday morning and think: I really should be doing something useful. You sit on the couch and feel restless. You plan a weekend away and notice that part of you is still occupied with what you would have done on a weekend like that before. That doesn’t automatically mean this happens to every former JW. But if you recognize it, you may ask yourself: Does something actually need to happen, or have I gotten used to the idea that free time has to be filled? Learning to tolerate rest can also be part of starting over. Who am I, really? Something much bigger than your schedule can also change. For some JWs, faith, social circle, morals, view of the future, and identity were closely intertwined for years. You may have known how you described yourself: I am one of Jehovah’s Witnesses. That may have come with an entire framework. What you believed. What future you expected. Which choices you considered important. Who your friends were. How you viewed relationships. What was right and wrong. What your purpose in life was. When part of that falls away, an unexpectedly big question can arise: Who am I without all of this? You don’t have to have an answer right away. You don’t have to choose a new identity A common thinking error after a major change is that the old answer must immediately be replaced by a new one. I was a JW, so what am I now? Atheist? Christian? Agnostic? Spiritual? Ex-JW? Maybe you don’t know yet. That’s allowed. You don’t have to know right away what you think about God, the Bible, Jehovah, religion, relationships, holidays, politics, sexuality, or all the other topics where you once had a clear framework. “I don’t know right now” is an answer too. It can even be an important in-between stage where, for the first time, you explore what you think without needing the outcome to be set in advance. Your values don’t disappear automatically when your faith does Maybe you ask yourself: If the organization no longer decides what is right and wrong, what do I base my choices on? You don’t start from zero. Honesty may still matter to you. Caring for others. Loyalty. Reliability. Love. Responsibility. Justice. Family. Friendship. You’re allowed to look again at why something matters to you. Not: What am I supposed to think? But: What do I value, why do I value it, and what effects do my choices have on myself and others? Some values you considered important as a JW you can keep. Others you may come to see differently. And perhaps you’ll discover values you gave little room to before. That process doesn’t have to be finished all at once. Watch out for a reversed identity There’s another trap too. Your identity may have first revolved mostly around Jehovah’s Witnesses and then become entirely about being ex-JW . You read constantly about the organization. You talk about it every day. You follow every change. You watch hours of ex-JW videos. You think a lot about what happened. That can be very understandable, and even helpful, for a while. You’re trying to make sense of your own history again. But eventually, this question may also arise: Who am I when my life no longer has to revolve around Jehovah’s Witnesses, but doesn’t have to revolve against them either? You are more than your religious past. Take information in manageable doses After leaving, there can be an enormous need for information. Maybe suddenly you want to know everything. 607 BCE. The Governing Body. Blood. Disfellowshipping. History. Old publications. Lawsuits. Other people’s experiences. Research can help you understand events and beliefs all over again. But you don’t have to spend every waking minute researching. When you notice that you’re constantly reading, sleeping badly, hardly thinking about anything else, or repeatedly seeking information to reassure yourself, it may be wise to build in deliberate breaks. Not because you shouldn’t keep investigating. But because your life is going on in the meantime too. Your feelings don’t have to follow one another logically One day you may think: Finally. The next day: What have I done? Then maybe: I never want to go back. And a week later: I miss everyone. That may seem contradictory, but different losses and longings can exist at the same time. You can be happy about your freedom and sad about people you miss. You can no longer believe certain teachings and still have warm memories of the congregation. You can be angry about events and still love active JW family members. You can be relieved that you stopped and afraid of Armageddon. One feeling doesn’t automatically make the other untrue. Longing to go back doesn’t automatically mean you want to return On a lonely Sunday you may suddenly long for the Kingdom Hall. Or for the friends you had there. For going somewhere together. For a convention. For singing. For the feeling that everyone had the same goal. Take such a feeling seriously, but don’t jump to a conclusion right away. Ask yourself: What exactly do I miss? Do I miss Jehovah? My faith? My family? My friends? The community? The certainty? The structure? The sense of belonging? Maybe you discover that you truly miss certain parts of your faith. That too is something you’re allowed to explore. ExJW.World doesn’t have to tell you what the answer should be. Be careful about trying to “catch up on everything” After years of not doing certain things, you may feel: Now I want to experience everything. Your first birthday. Christmas. Going out. Dating. Sex. Alcohol. Festivals. A tattoo. Different clothes. New friends. Some things may turn out to be amazing. Others not at all. Freedom does not mean you now have to do the opposite of what Jehovah’s Witnesses teach. Then the organization would still be partly determining what you do — just in reverse. The more interesting question is: Would I want this even if it had nothing to do with my past as one of Jehovah’s Witnesses? You don’t have to make up for lost time to prove you’re free. First build a gentle rhythm Total freedom sounds appealing, but people usually need some structure. So you can create a new rhythm without turning your life into an overpacked schedule all over again. Think, for example, of fixed sleep and wake-up times, work or study, exercise, groceries, an evening when you see someone, time outdoors, a hobby, and also making sure there are moments when nothing is planned. The goal is not: to replace my old schedule as quickly as possible. But: to discover what rhythm is good for me. Experiment in small ways You don’t have to know right away what your hobbies are. Try things. Go for a walk. Work out. Read something you’re curious about. Take a class. Go get coffee somewhere on your own. Visit a museum. Learn to cook. Make music. Volunteer. Go to an event. Not every activity has to become a life purpose. You’re allowed to try something once and think: No, this isn’t for me. That’s information about who you are too. Getting to know new people takes time A congregation offered something that doesn’t automatically exist outside a religious community: recurring contact with the same people. New friendships usually don’t happen because you show up somewhere once. They grow through repetition. That’s why places where you keep running into the same people can be helpful: sports, volunteering, a course, an association, work, study, or another recurring activity. You don’t have to find a new “congregation” right away. A few reliable contacts can already mean a lot. Five things you don’t have to know today You don’t need to know today: whether you’ll ever go back; what exactly you believe about God; how you label yourself religiously or non-religiously; what your new social life will eventually look like; who you’ll be in five years. You’re allowed to change your mind along the way. When professional help may be wise Leaving a religious community is not a mental disorder. Grief, doubt, or temporarily not knowing who you are does not automatically mean you need therapy either. But professional help can be wise when anxiety, depression, panic, sleep problems, guilt, trauma symptoms, or loss of functioning become severe or last a long time. And if family rifts, shunning, or the loss of your social network weigh heavily on you, it can be comforting to talk to someone who is not trying to decide whether you should return or stay away. A good counselor doesn’t have to judge your faith for you. He or she can help you explore what you think, feel, need, and want. A small exercise for your first weeks Take a sheet of paper and make three columns: This I miss This I don’t miss This I don’t know yet Write without correcting yourself. Maybe under This I miss : my mother, singing, certainty, friends. Under This I don’t miss : getting up early, certain expectations, meetings. And under This I don’t know yet : Jehovah, the Bible, Christmas, new relationships, who I want to be. That third column matters. You don’t have to move everything to yes or no right away. In closing Stopping doesn’t have to be an endpoint. It can be a transition between a life whose parts were familiar and a life whose shape you don’t yet quite know. Maybe that feels freeing. Maybe empty. Maybe both. You don’t have to fill that emptiness immediately. You don’t have to choose a new belief just because the old one has started to shift. You don’t have to try everything that used to fall outside your life. You also don’t have to prove that leaving was the right decision. You’re allowed to discover first. What do I miss? What do I want to keep? What do I want to leave behind? What do I still believe? What don’t I know? What gives me energy? What kind of people do I want around me? And maybe especially: If no one told me what my new life is supposed to look like, how would I want to slowly build it myself? Also read on ExJW.World I miss my community - Do you miss your faith, the people, the structure, or the feeling of belonging? Grieving a faith - Why changing or losing a faith can also be a process of grief. Rebuilding your social life after leaving the congregation: from structure to freedom - Practical steps to build a new social network again. I want professional help - How do you find someone who makes room for your own convictions and choices?